Football

Coe College Football All-Americans

 
  Name Year Award
Tommy Breitbach 2007 D3football.com All-America Honorable Mention (RET)
Ashton Northern 2006
Don Hansen's Football Gazette
All-American - Honorable Mention RB
Adam Jordison 2006
Don Hansen's Football Gazette
All- American - Honorable Mention DE
Frederick Jackson 2002
American Football Coaches Association (AFCA)
Hewlett Packard - First Team
Don Hansen's Football Gazette - First Team (Ret)
Don Hansen's Football Gazette - Second Team (RB)
D3Football.com - Second Team

 Scott Schara 2001 All-American Honorable Mention

 Tim Vinyard 2000 Academic All-American

 Zak Gordon 1999 All-American

 Jason Juran 1999 All-American
Ray Neosh 1997 All-American - Hewleww Packard

 Brian Collier 1997 Academic All-American

 Jason Hocker 1997 Academic All-American

 Ray Neosh 1996 All-American - Third Team

 Carey Bender 1994 All-American
Carey Bender 1993 Kodak/Champion All-American - First Team
Marcus Adkins 1993 GTE Academic All-American - First Team

 Craig Chmelicek 1993 Champion All-American - First Team

 Tim Smyth 1993 Champion All-American - Second Team

 A.J. Styre 1993 Honorable Mention - All-American
Mike Canney 1992 All-American - Second Team
Richard Matthews 1992 Honorable Mention - All-American

 Jason Martin 1992 Honorable Mention - All-American
Steve Bohr 1991 Academic All-American - Second Team
Richard Matthews 1991 Honorable Mention - All-American
Marcus Adkins 1990 GTE All-American - Second Team

 Richard Matthews 1990
Ass. Press All-American - First Team
All-American - Second Team
Gary Crock 1990 All-American - Third Team

 Ryan Koplin 1990 Honorable Mention - All-American

 Sean Lyness 1990 Honorable Mention - All-American

 Sean Healy 1989 All-American - Second Team

 John Costello 1989 All-American - Second Team

 Brent Thurness 1988 Academic All-American

 Brad Wimmer 1987 Academic All-American

 Harold Phillips 1986 All-American

 Jim Dostal 1986 All-American

 Mike Matzen 1985 All-American
Harold Phillips 1985 All-American

 T.J. Stecklein 1981 Academic All-American

 David Showalter 1980 Academic All-American

 Glen McCord 1977 Academic All-American

 Paul Wagner 1976 All-American

 Dan Schmitt 1974 All-American

 Jim Pater 1959 All-American

 Roger Higgins 1956 All-American

 George Cilek 1955 All-American

 Elliot "Shady" Day 1955 Honorable Mention - All-American

 Elliot "Shady" Day 1954 Honorable Mention - All-Amerian

 Doug Hamilton 1952 All-American

 Charles Lighter 1931 All-American